Prop account rules: is your strategy even eligible?
Prop accounts get shopped on two numbers: the drawdown width and the monthly price. Neither one can delete a strategy. A session rule can, and it does it completely.
So here is the rule everybody thinks they understand. Topstep says "No swing trading." Take Profit Trader says positions "may not be held from one session to the next." Apex prohibits "holding open trade positions through the market close," on pain of forfeiting the account and all its balances. Read those three lines and you would conclude that an overnight strategy is dead at all three firms.
That conclusion is wrong. The futures trading session does not start in the morning. It starts the evening before. Topstep's weekday session opens at 5:00 PM CT and closes at 3:10 PM CT the next day. Take Profit Trader's runs 6:00 PM ET to 5:00 PM ET. Apex's runs 6:00 PM ET to 4:59 PM ET.
Our overnight strategy enters at 18:15 ET and exits at 08:30 ET. It crosses the calendar day. It does not cross a single one of those session boundaries.
On our book, that distinction decides 16.2 percent of net profit. Same strategy, same trades. Whether it is eligible or forbidden depends entirely on whether "overnight" means "past midnight" or "past the session close", and the firms mean the second one.
Check the firm's published session hours, not the word "overnight". The session opens the evening before, so a hold that runs from evening into the next morning never leaves the session it started in.
Whose trades are these
One systematic NQ book: four rules-based strategies running a single position at a time on Nasdaq 100 futures. Window 2011 to 2026, data as of November 6, 2026. Our full hypothetical trade record: 3,139 closed trades, net $696,892, on a $100,000 nominal basis, 1 or 2 NQ minis a trade: 2 when daily ranges are small, 1 when they are large; at today's index level every trade since July 2024 has been 1 contract.
The numbers here are a property of a momentum book that holds trades for hours, not minutes. A scalper who is flat by 10 AM is eligible almost everywhere and can stop reading. The method transfers to any trader. The exact percentages do not.
How much of our NQ book's profit does each strategy earn?
Inside our backtested single-slot book, Trend earns 31.1% of net profit, Opening Range Break 28.2%, VWAP Short 24.5% and Overnight 16.2 percent.
| Strategy | Trades | Share of book net |
|---|---|---|
| Trend | 940 | 31.1% |
| Opening Range Break | 972 | 28.2% |
| VWAP Short | 419 | 24.5% |
| Overnight | 808 | 16.2 percent |
One caveat on that table. These are shares of net profit earned inside the single-slot book, where the four strategies compete for one position. That is a different basis from the standalone per-strategy figures on our strategies page, where each runs alone with no contention. We do not mix the two bases. The in-book basis is used throughout, because it is what a subscriber following the signals would actually have traded. How each of the four works is published in full.
Can I hold NQ overnight at Topstep, Apex or Take Profit Trader?
On published hours, our 18:15 to 08:30 ET hold crosses no session boundary at Topstep, Apex or Take Profit Trader. Topstep's FAQ says "No" to holding overnight, but defines it as holding "from one session to the next", which this hold does not do.
Our overnight strategy's shape is fixed: in at 18:15 ET, out at 08:30 ET. The question is only whether that path crosses each firm's session boundary. Draw the day on one clock and the answer stops being a reading comprehension exercise.
| Firm | Session as the firm publishes it | Does an 18:15 to 08:30 ET hold cross it? |
|---|---|---|
| Topstep | Opens 5:00 PM CT, closes 3:10 PM CT next day | No. Both ends sit inside one session. |
| Take Profit Trader | 6:00 PM ET to 5:00 PM ET, auto-close 4:55 PM ET | No. TPT counts a trade opened at or after 6 PM ET toward that new trading day. |
| Apex | 6:00 PM ET to 4:59 PM ET | No. The position never sits through the market close. |
On the published hours, the strategy survives at all three.
Topstep's FAQ, on the same help page as its hours table, asks: "Can I swing trade or hold positions overnight?" The answer: "No. All positions must be closed by 3:10 PM CT each weekday. Topstep does not permit holding positions from one session to the next." That "No" defines itself: the rule is the session boundary, and the page's hours table puts the boundary at 3:10 PM CT. An evening-to-morning hold never reaches it. We read "overnight" in the question as "across sessions", not "past midnight" (FAQ read 2026-08-04).
Read the firm's definition, not the word. At all three firms the trading day starts in the evening, so a hold from evening to the next morning stays inside one session.
Apex and Take Profit Trader are more direct. Apex's prohibition is anchored to a specific event, the market close, and our strategy is never open at it. TPT's is anchored to the session and defines the session start explicitly enough that the answer falls out.
Does Topstep's force-close time cut NQ trades short?
Yes. Topstep flattens at 3:10 PM CT, which is 4:10 PM ET, 35 minutes before our 4:45 PM ET exit, and 1,054 of our 3,139 backtested trades, 33.6%, are still open then. In our 50K evaluation replay at two micros per signal, that cut Topstep's pass rate from 74.8% to 66.0%. Priced at 4:10 PM ET, it removes a hypothetical 4.5% of net profit on the trades we could price. Take Profit Trader and Apex both fit our exit.
The overnight question is the one traders ask. The deadline question is the one that quietly reshapes an intraday book, and almost nobody checks it.
Our book's end-of-day exit fires at 4:45 PM ET. Line the three firms up against it:
| Firm | Force-close time | Our 4:45 PM ET exit |
|---|---|---|
| Topstep | 3:10 PM CT, which is 4:10 PM ET | Closed 35 minutes early |
| Take Profit Trader | 4:55 PM ET auto-close | Fits, with 10 minutes to spare |
| Apex | before 4:59 PM ET | Fits |
1,054 of our 3,139 trades, 33.6%, are still open at the 4:10 PM ET flatten. Overnight trades are not among them: they close in the morning. The 1,054 carry the book's profit. They earned a hypothetical $1,719,145, while the other 2,085 trades lost $1,022,253.
By 4:10 PM those trades had earned almost all of it. We closed each one at its 4:10 PM price from an independent NQ price record, keeping its entry, commission and slippage. That removes a hypothetical $31,395, 4.5% of the book's $696,892 net. 96 of the 1,054 trades, carrying $213,501 of net and 90 of them in 2025 and 2026, fall in gaps in that record and keep their actual exit. If they gave up the same share as the trades we could price, the total would be about 5.1%.
The cost lands unevenly. We replayed a 50K evaluation ($3,000 target, $2,000 end-of-day trailing drawdown, Topstep's 55%-of-target consistency cap) from every start date in the record. At two micros per signal, each paying Topstep's $1.22 round trip, the flatten cut Topstep's pass rate from 74.8% to 66.0%, mostly on 2016 to 2020 start dates; at one NQ mini the pass rate did not fall (33.4% without the flatten, 34.1% with it). The hour-by-hour breakdown of where a book's profit falls across the trading day is in when NQ actually pays.
The overnight rule is the one traders check, and on published hours it does not bite. The force-close deadline is the one nobody checks: it reaches 33.6% of our trades, the ones that carry the profit, though pricing them at the deadline shows most of the gain is already in. Take your own latest exit time, convert it into the firm's timezone, and compare it to their flatten time before you buy anything.
Is an intraday or end-of-day trailing drawdown better for prop firms?
For a high-excursion system, end-of-day is the friendlier one. An intraday trail ratchets on unrealized peaks, and our median winner peaks at 41.9 points and closes at 24.5, so the floor rises on profit the account never banked.
The third eligibility question is the drawdown mechanic. All three firms use a $2,000 trailing drawdown on a 50K account, so the width decides nothing. What differs is what moves the floor up. An end-of-day trailing drawdown ratchets on your closing balance. An intraday trailing drawdown ratchets on your peak balance including unrealized gains. Apex states it plainly: "The threshold is enforced in real time, including unrealized PnL."
That is a tax on one specific kind of trade: the one that runs far in your favour and gives some back. A trade that reaches +$1,400 and closes +$600 has, under an intraday trail, permanently lifted your floor by the full $1,400 while paying you $600. You banked $600 and spent $1,400 of buffer.
Our book is full of those by design. The median winner peaks at 41.9 points of favorable excursion and closes at 24.5. That gap is not a defect to optimise away, it is what a trend-continuation exit looks like.
Measured trade by trade rather than as two separate medians, the same pattern holds across all 1,423 winners in the book.
A book shaped like that consumes an intraday trailing buffer far faster than its closed-trade equity curve suggests, because the floor ratchets on profit the account never banked. If you trade a high-excursion system the end-of-day product is the structurally friendlier one, and at Apex that is a product choice made at purchase: a funded account matches the type of the evaluation it came from. We replayed the same book against every current 50K product's floor and lock point in three prop firms tested on our book. The lock point, not the brand, decided survival.
Width tells you nothing. The question is whether the floor ratchets on your closing balance or on your unrealized peaks. A trend-continuation book gives back a third of its peak profit by design, and an intraday trail charges you for every point of it.
Can I place TradingView orders at Topstep, Apex or Take Profit Trader?
Topstep does not support TradingView order entry at any stage. Apex allows it via Tradovate, and Take Profit Trader allows it. Apex and Take Profit Trader both prohibit automated execution at the funded stage.
A strategy you cannot physically place is as ineligible as one the rules forbid. We deliver our signals as real-time alerts you act on yourself, so where you can place the order matters.
| Firm | TradingView order entry | Automated execution, funded stage |
|---|---|---|
| Topstep | Not supported, at any stage | Permitted with conditions; not via the ProjectX API on a Live Funded Account |
| Take Profit Trader | Yes, and free during the Test, on a CQG feed | Prohibited. "No Trading Bots or Algos" |
| Apex | Yes, via Tradovate | Prohibited. "No Automation or Algorithm Usage allowed" |
Two of the three prohibit automation outright at the funded stage, in their own words. Apex: "Rewards are intended to recognize human traders actively participating in the learning process, not to reward automated systems executing preprogrammed logic." Take Profit Trader, in policies that explicitly cover Test, PRO and PRO+: "Automated trading systems, bots, or algorithmic execution tools are not permitted."
Reading signals off a chart and placing the orders yourself is not automated execution, and the bot rules are not aimed at you. But the platform rule is: on Topstep you cannot place orders from an outside charting platform, at any stage. TopstepX "cannot connect to external platforms like TradingView." That is not a preference, it is the product.
What to do before you pay
Four questions, in this order, all answerable in an afternoon.
One: what does this firm call a session, and when does it start? Not what "overnight" means to you. What the session boundary is on their published hours page. That definition, not the word, decides whether a Globex strategy lives.
Two: what time is my last exit? Not the average, the latest. Compare it to the firm's force-close time in one timezone. Most deadlines are published in CT and most charts are in ET, and that one-hour slip is where people get caught.
Three: how much does my average winner give back from its peak? If the answer is "a lot", an intraday trailing drawdown is charging you for profit you never collected. Prefer end-of-day where you get the choice, and remember the choice can be permanent.
Four: can I physically place the order from the tool I actually use? Check before you pay. Platform choice at Apex cannot be converted later and is explicitly non-refundable.
None of these is the number on the pricing page. All four can disqualify you. The pricing-page fee is not the real bill either, because failed attempts add up; we priced that in combine reset math.
Clearing all four only makes you eligible. Whether money ever leaves the account is decided by a second rulebook that no evaluation page shows you. We took that one apart in getting funded is not getting paid, and its sharpest rule for a book like ours in the consistency rule vs fat-tailed systems.
The limits of this analysis
Every rule here was read on the firm's own live page on the date stamped beside it, and the source pages are linked at the end. Prop firms change rules without notice. Apex re-ruled its entire product line on 1 March 2026 and is currently re-selling a legacy product with different numbers under a promotion.
Firm help pages are not always consistent from one page to the next. Re-read the rule yourself before acting on it. We are not affiliated with any prop firm.
On our side: the strategy shares are the in-book, single-slot basis on the trade record as of November 6, 2026, and they reconcile to the book's net of $696,892 on 3,139 trades.
We publish those shares as percentages only, so this article does not introduce a second per-strategy dollar basis alongside the standalone figures already on the site. The peak-giveback figures are per-trade ratios of net profit to each trade's peak favorable excursion, taken over the 1,423 winning trades. They are percentages by construction and carry no dollar basis at all.
Exit times are exchange time. The cost of Topstep's early force-close is priced from an independent NQ price record, as described above. All of this is hypothetical backtest performance, not a live account and not a payout record.
The eligibility question is the one part of prop-account selection that is fully knowable in advance, from published rules and your own trade export, with no forecasting involved. It is also the part most traders skip, and the part where the published rules are least careful.
Where these rules came from
Every firm rule above was read in a browser, on the firm's own live page, on the date stamped beside it. No search snippets, no cached pages, no third-party comparison sites: prop firms retire rules faster than the rest of the web catches up, and a retired rule reads exactly like a current one. The pages this article works from:
- Topstep: trading hours and products, TopstepX, Express Funded Account parameters
- Apex: prohibited activities, futures trading times, intraday trailing drawdown explained
- Take Profit Trader: Universal Trading Policies, trading hours, TradingView support
Any of these can change tomorrow with no announcement. Read the page yourself before you pay, and if it now says something other than what is quoted here, the firm's page wins.
Every trade behind these numbers is on the tear sheet, the strategies are on our strategies page, and the signals are what we sell.
See what STS NQ futures signals are and how they reach you and our forward record, every live signal we have sent, dated and public.
Disclosure. We trade this book live and sell access to the signals, so judge the data accordingly. This article is educational and is not investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer to buy or sell any security or futures contract, and it is not a recommendation of any prop firm or account type. We have no affiliation with Topstep, Apex Trader Funding, Take Profit Trader, or any prop firm. Every rule cited was read on the firm's own live page on the date shown and can change at any time.