Does an NQ overnight trading strategy actually have an edge? A backtest from 2012 to 2026
Yes, but as a diversifier, not a lone edge. Our overnight NQ strategy made $113,118 over 808 trades from 2012 to 2026 at the book's highest win rate, 56.3%, with a Sharpe of 0.89. What earns it a slot is when it trades: it buys in the 6 PM ET hour and is out before the 9:30 a.m. open, hours in which our day strategies never open a trade. It made 16.2% of the book's net profit in time the rest of the book does not use.
The folklore is that the S&P and Nasdaq drift up overnight while the day session churns. Some of that is real. But "buy the close, sell the open" is not what we run, and a naive drift trade would have handed most of its gains back in fills and bad nights. What we run is a momentum rule that only holds overnight when the prior session earned it. We looked at which day-session hours actually carry our edge in the best time to trade NQ futures; this is the after-hours companion to that.
Is an overnight NQ strategy profitable in backtests?
Our backtested overnight strategy made $113,118 over 808 trades from Jan 2012 to Oct 2026, with a 56.3% win rate, a 1.40 profit factor and a $16,889 max drawdown.
Here is the whole argument in one table. Every number is from our own trade export: the strategy's own trades inside the book.
| Metric | Overnight strategy | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Net profit | $113,118 | Sum of net P&L, 808 trades |
| Trades | 808 | Over 14.7 years (Jan 2012 to Oct 2026) |
| Win rate | 56.3% | Highest of any strategy in our book |
| Profit factor | 1.40 | Gross wins / gross losses |
| Sharpe (annualized) | 0.89 | All weekdays, non-trading days zero-filled, running-equity denominator, x sqrt(252). Same basis as the book's 1.27, so the two are comparable |
| Sortino | 1.38 | Downside-only, same basis as the Sharpe above |
| Expectancy | $140 / trade | Net / trades |
| Skew (% returns) | -0.25 | On volatility-normalized returns (dollar basis differs, see below) |
| Excess kurtosis (% returns) | -0.2 | Below normal on the % basis (dollar basis differs, see below) |
| Max drawdown | $16,889 | Worst peak-to-trough on its own equity curve (11.7% of that curve's peak) |
| Hours | 6:15 PM to before 9:30 AM ET | Hours our day strategies never open a trade, the reason it earns its slot |
The skew and kurtosis numbers deserve a careful read, because they depend on how you measure a trade. On volatility-normalized returns (each trade as a percent of the capital it risked), skew is -0.25 and excess kurtosis is -0.2, both below a normal distribution: no outlier trade dominates once you account for position size. Raw dollar P&L keeps the contract count and the price level of NQ in. On that dollar basis skew is +0.05, close to even, and excess kurtosis is +3.5: fatter tails than normal on both sides. Both are true; they answer different questions. The percent basis tells you the per-unit-risk edge is broad-based; the dollar basis tells you your realized P&L will have some outsized nights, good and bad. We flag both rather than quote only the flattering one.
Average win is $865, average loss is $794, a payoff of 1.09. Combine that with a 56.3% win rate and the math works without needing a home run. It wins a bit more than half the time and wins slightly bigger than it loses.
Whose trades are these
Our book is four systematic NQ strategies (Trend, Opening Range Break, VWAP Short and Overnight) run as one single-position account, backtested on TradingView from 2011 to 2026 at 1 or 2 NQ minis a trade: 2 when daily ranges are small, 1 when they are large; at today's index level every trade since July 2024 has been 1 contract. Overnight is the one strategy that trades outside the day session. Every one of its trades is a long. It buys in the 6 PM ET hour when the prior session's trend is up, holds through the Globex overnight session, and exits on a morning rule before the 9:30 a.m. open (679 of 808 trades), or earlier on its stop or target (129).
It is a momentum strategy, not mean reversion, and not scalping. Everything below is conditional on that style. "Overnight NQ has an edge" is our shorthand for "this specific momentum-into-Globex rule had an edge on NQ." A different overnight rule could do the opposite. We are not claiming the overnight session is free money.
Does an overnight NQ strategy overlap with day trading strategies?
Not in time. It buys only in the 6 PM ET hour and is out before the 9:30 a.m. open, while our three day strategies open their trades between 9 a.m. and 4 p.m. ET. It does share days: on 433 of the 802 days it closed a trade, a day strategy closed one too.
A strategy does not need to be the best one in the book to belong in it. It needs to make money doing something the others do not. That is what buys you a smoother equity curve.
The book holds one position at a time. This strategy is always out before the day strategies' first entry, so it never takes a slot from them. It earns its money in hours the book would otherwise sit flat: 16.2% of the book's net profit from 25.7% of its trades.
This is why we keep it even though, as you will see, it does not clear our solo-edge bar. Separate hours are not the same as separate risk, though. Because it shares so many days with the day strategies, a bad night and a bad day can land on the same date, and we do not claim more for it than the hours show. We wrote about why streams that do not move together matter in why a book of low-correlation systems beats one.
The honest limit: it does not clear our solo-edge bar
Standalone, the overnight strategy's per-trade t-stat is 2.93 on volatility-normalized returns (naive-IID, assuming independent trades). Our own anti-overfit rule says a fresh standalone edge needs a t-stat above 3 before we would trust it on its own. On this per-unit-risk basis, the overnight strategy does not clear it.
We use the percent basis on purpose, and we will show our work. On raw dollar P&L the same 808 trades give a t-stat of 3.14, which does clear 3. The gap is size. The percent basis divides each trade by the dollar value of the contracts it held, which strips out both the contract count and NQ's price level at the time. A dollar t-stat keeps them in, so it rewards the strategy for having been bigger, in dollars, in its best stretches. That is a real part of the backtested result, but a weaker test of whether the underlying edge is genuine. The percent basis asks the harder question, is the per-trade edge itself significant, and there the answer is a hair light. We hold ourselves to the harder test. And even 2.93 is optimistic, because naive-IID treats every night as independent; overnight momentum trades cluster in regimes, so the effective number of independent bets is below 808 and the true standalone t is somewhat lower still.
So we do not treat it as a bulletproof solo strategy. It stays in the book for one reason: it makes money in hours the rest of the book never trades. Take it out on its own and pitch it as a standalone system, and we would tell you the per-unit-risk t-stat is a hair light. Inside a book of four streams, that same strategy pulls its weight. Stacking marginal edges that trade at different times, like this one, is the method we set out in how to build a profitable NQ strategy.
There is a second limit worth stating plainly. These figures inherit TradingView's fill model. The robustness checks below (Monte Carlo, tick jitter) are what-ifs applied to those backtested trades, not fresh in-engine backtests. They stress the result; they do not backtest the strategy again from scratch.
Does the overnight NQ backtest survive Monte Carlo and slippage tests?
Mostly. Across 5,000 resamples the 2.5th-percentile net stays at $41,889, and profit factor is above 1 in all 12 rolling four-year windows. Slippage is its weak spot: an average of 3 extra ticks per round trip cuts net by 20.1% and drops the t-stat to 1.77.
We ran three stress tests on the 808-trade stream. All are seeded, so they reproduce exactly.
Monte Carlo (5,000 resamples). We resampled the trade sequence with replacement 5,000 times. The 2.5th-percentile net stays at $41,889, still positive, and 99.9% of resamples made money. Even a bad draw of these trades makes money. Median simulated max drawdown is $18,418; the 97.5th percentile is $36,165. History served up $16,889, less than the median, so more than half of the resamples drew down further than history did. Plan for more than the worst you have seen.
Tick jitter (1 to 3 ticks). First we added random noise: every entry and exit fill moved up to 3 ticks either way, at random. Net and the t-stat barely move; the t-stat median holds at 2.94. Then we made fills worse on purpose, by a random 0 to 3 ticks per fill, which works out to an average of 1, 2 or 3 extra ticks per round trip. That does bite. At 1 extra tick, net falls 6.7% and the t-stat median falls to 2.55. At 2 ticks, net falls 13.4% and the t-stat to 2.16. At 3 ticks, net falls 20.1% and the t-stat to 1.77, below the 2 we treat as noise (on the dollar basis it falls from 3.14 to 2.51). These ticks come on top of the costs already in the backtest. The strategy averages $94 a contract per trade after costs, and one tick is $5 a contract, so a few ticks is a real slice of the edge. It does not need lucky fills, but it does need fair ones.
Rolling stability. Profit factor stays above 1 in all 12 rolling four-year windows (the lowest is 1.03, for 2012 to 2015). These windows overlap by three years each, so treat this as a smoothness read, not 12 independent trials. By calendar year, which does not overlap, it is positive in 11 of 14, best year +$25,236 (2025), worst -$10,568 (2018). It has losing years. It does not have a losing decade.
Methodology
- Instrument: NQ (E-mini Nasdaq-100 futures), CME, continuous contract, contract-roll rebased.
- Data and window: the overnight strategy's own trades inside the book run 24 Jan 2012 to 12 Oct 2026, 14.7 years, 808 trades. The full four-strategy book spans November 16, 2011 to November 6, 2026, 15 years. The overnight strategy itself is 14.7 years; we lead with the honest count.
- Costs: commissions and slippage are baked into the net P&L per trade.
- Sizing: 1 or 2 NQ minis a trade (2 when daily ranges are small, 1 when they are large; at today's index level every trade since July 2024 has been 1 contract), single position across the whole book. This strategy traded 2 contracts on 707 trades and 1 on 101.
- Basis for higher-moment stats: skew, kurtosis, and the solo t-stat are computed on volatility-normalized (percent) returns, which strip out position size. On raw dollar P&L the same trades show fatter tails on both sides (skew +0.05, excess kurtosis +3.5) and a higher t-stat (3.14); both are reported in the body. We lead with the percent basis because it is the harder test of the underlying edge.
- Sharpe and Sortino basis: both are on the same basis as the book's 1.27 / 2.36, namely daily returns over every weekday in the strategy's span with non-trading days zero-filled, a running-equity denominator, annualised by sqrt(252). A narrower basis that counts only the 802 days this strategy actually closed a trade is not wrong arithmetic, but it charges the ratio for 802 days of risk and annualises it over 252, which flatters a strategy that trades on a fifth of the calendar far more than it flatters the book. On one ruler the strategy scores 0.89 against the book's 1.27, which is the ordinary result of diversification and the reason the strategy is run inside a book rather than alone.
- Drawdown percent: the $16,889 max drawdown is 11.7% of the $143,929 peak of the strategy's own equity curve, started at $100,000. On a fixed $100,000 basis it is 16.9%. We cite the dollar figure and both percents, each with its basis, to avoid ambiguity.
- What would falsify this: if it traded the same hours as the day strategies, the "separate hours" case collapses and we should drop it. If the t-stat were below 2 on both bases, we would not run it at all. If the per-unit-risk profit came from a few outlier trades (high positive percent-basis skew and kurtosis), the "broad-based" claim would be false. None of those held at the backtest's fills. Steady slippage of about 3 extra ticks a round trip does push the percent-basis t-stat below 2, so fills are the thing to watch.
You can reproduce the tear sheet from our trade export. If you want to see how we audit any track record for these traps, we wrote it up in how to audit a trading track record.
Copy-paste: the four checks before you trust any overnight backtest
Before you believe any "overnight NQ makes money" chart, run these four on the trade list:
1. Overlap with your day trades -> same hours, or monthly correlation > 0.4, means it is
not really a diversifier
2. Skew and excess kurtosis -> compute on BOTH % and dollar P&L; if the % basis is fat
right-tailed, a few risk-adjusted trades carry it
3. Per-trade t-stat (% returns) -> below ~2, it is noise; 2 to 3, diversifier only; >3, solo edge
4. Rolling 4-year profit factor -> if it is not > 1 in most windows, it is regime luck
Our overnight strategy passes 2 and 4 cleanly and lands in the "diversifier only" band on 3. On 1 it shares no hours with our day strategies, though it does share many days. That is an honest place for it to sit.
Where this goes next
The interesting question is not whether the overnight strategy is a solo edge. We already know it is not. The question is whether a second stream that trades while the book sits flat can add profit the way this one does, without deepening the book's worst stretches. That is the next test: find or build another sleeve for the empty hours and measure what it does to the whole book's drawdown, not just its own. See the full set of live streams on our strategies, or the current book tear sheet on the tearsheet. If you want the signals themselves, that is what access is for.
Conflict disclosure: We trade this book live and sell access to the signals. Judge the data on its merits and reproduce it yourself; we have every incentive to show it in a good light, which is exactly why every number here traces to a raw trade export and is computed two independent ways.
CFTC Rule 4.41: Hypothetical or simulated performance results have certain limitations. Unlike an actual performance record, simulated results do not represent actual trading. Also, since the trades have not actually been executed, the results may have under- or over-compensated for the impact, if any, of certain market factors, such as lack of liquidity. Simulated trading programs in general are also subject to the fact that they are designed with the benefit of hindsight. No representation is being made that any account will or is likely to achieve profit or losses similar to those shown.
Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results. Futures trading involves substantial risk of loss and is not suitable for every investor.
See what STS NQ futures signals are and how they reach you and our forward record, every live signal we have sent, dated and public.