TopStep vs Apex vs MFFU: we tested the 50k rules on our 15-year backtested NQ book

On the correct, current $2,000 50k drawdown rules, TopStep, Apex (end-of-day) and MyFundedFutures are byte-for-byte identical on our book: replay our backtested 3,139-trade NQ sequence through all three at two micros and they bust at the same trade, on the same day, at the same floor. The old comparison-blog line that "Apex is most forgiving" was true only under Apex's legacy $2,500 floor, which is a separate product line Apex still sells alongside the current one rather than a retired rule (verified on Apex's own pages, 2026-08-03); on the current $2,000 floor that claim is false. What actually decides whether a backtested 15-year book survives is not the brand, it is the drawdown lock point and the trading platform: one micro contract on any lock-at-breakeven product survives 97.5% of possible start dates, while Apex's still-trailing evaluation floor on Tradovate, which never locks, busts the same book 99.4% of the time. At two micros, an account funded at the start of the record busts on every current product, and even the best products bust on 18.3% of start dates.

Whose trades are these

One systematic NQ book, four strategies (Trend, Opening Range Break, VWAP Short and Overnight) sharing a single position at a time. Window: November 16, 2011 to November 6, 2026. From a TradingView List-of-Trades export dated November 6, 2026: 3,139 closed trades, net $696,891.60 on a $100,000 nominal basis, across 2,291 distinct exit days. The book itself trades 1 or 2 NQ minis a trade (2 when daily ranges are small, 1 when they are large; at today's index level every trade since July 2024 has been 1 contract). We did not model a generic ruleset an affiliate blog could publish. We replayed our own backtested trade sequence in its actual historical order, with each trade's maximum favorable and adverse excursion, against each firm's trailing-drawdown floor as a state machine, and recorded which firm and size the book survives. That replay is the one comparison only we can run.

Scale matters before anything else. The mini (NQ, $20 per point) is an instant kill on any $2,000 floor: the book's worst intrabar drawdown is $28,515, 14.3 times the floor, and one mini on every signal has the same worst intrabar drawdown. The only viable unit is the MNQ micro ($2 per point). Even there, one micro on every signal has a worst intrabar drawdown of $2,851, 1.43 times a $2,000 floor, which is why a floor that keeps trailing cannot hold this book and a floor that locks can. "One micro" below means exactly one MNQ on every signal, the smallest size a follower can trade; "two micros" means two on every signal. If a product busts at one micro, it cannot be run at all.

What is the bust rate on a prop firm 50k account at one micro?

Run every current 50k product over all 2,291 historical fund dates at one micro, and the bust rate ranges from 2.5% to 99.4%. That spread is almost entirely explained by two things: where the drawdown floor stops trailing (locks), and which platform trails it.

Product, 50k Ratchet basis Where the floor locks Bust rate at 1 micro (2,291 starts)
TopStep Combine and funded end-of-day $50,000 (breakeven) 2.5%
Apex funded (PA), EOD; MFFU EOD plans end-of-day ~$50,100 (start + $100) 2.5%
Apex funded (PA), intraday; MFFU Rapid once funded intraday ~$50,100 (start + $100) 3.7%
Apex EOD evaluation (Rithmic/WealthCharts) end-of-day $53,000 (profit target) 3.9%
Apex intraday evaluation (Rithmic/WealthCharts) intraday $53,000 (profit target) 8.1%
MFFU Builder $1,500 add-on end-of-day ~$50,100 (start + $100) 12.6%
Any Apex evaluation on Tradovate either never locks (trails forever) 99.4%
Horizontal bar chart of one-micro bust rate across 2,291 start dates by 50k product: TopStep 2.5%, Apex/MFFU end-of-day breakeven 2.5%, Apex intraday PA and MFFU Rapid funded 3.7%, Apex EOD evaluation on Rithmic 3.9%, Apex intraday evaluation on Rithmic 8.1%, MFFU Builder $1,500 12.6%, any Apex evaluation on Tradovate 99.4%. Lock point and platform, not brand, drive the spread. Horizontal bar chart of one-micro bust rate across 2,291 start dates by 50k product: TopStep 2.5%, Apex/MFFU end-of-day breakeven 2.5%, Apex intraday PA and MFFU Rapid funded 3.7%, Apex EOD evaluation on Rithmic 3.9%, Apex intraday evaluation on Rithmic 8.1%, MFFU Builder $1,500 12.6%, any Apex evaluation on Tradovate 99.4%. Lock point and platform, not brand, drive the spread.
One-micro bust rate over 2,291 historical start dates. The 2.5% to 99.4% spread tracks the lock point and platform, not the logo.

Step up in size and the picture changes fast. At two micros the bust rate runs from 18.3% on TopStep to 44.7% on Apex's intraday evaluation, and 99.8% on Tradovate; at three micros, from 40.5% to 99.9%. There is no current 50k product on which this book reliably survives at two or more micros, and Tradovate busts more than 99% of start dates at every size.

Are TopStep, Apex and MFFU 50k rules really different?

Not on our book. At two micros, every $2,000 end-of-day 50k product from TopStep, Apex and MFFU busts at the identical point, trade #420 on August 29, 2013, and the intraday products bust one trade earlier, at #419.

Fund at inception in 2011 and trade the whole book at one micro, and every product whose floor locks survives to the end of the record; only Apex's Tradovate evaluations bust, the intraday one at trade #2312 in May 2022 and the end-of-day one at trade #3083 in July 2026. Step up to two micros and every current 50k product busts. The entire $2,000 end-of-day cluster (TopStep Combine, Apex EOD evaluation, Apex EOD funded, MFFU Rapid evaluation, MFFU Builder $2,000, MFFU Pro, MFFU Flex) busts at the identical point: trade #420, August 29, 2013, floor at $48,000, balance $48,010. The $2,000 intraday products bust one trade earlier, at #419, August 28, 2013. Seven separately branded products failing at the same trade, on the same day, is the proof that on our book they are not different machines.

First-bust trade number, fund-at-inception at two micros: the seven-product $2,000 end-of-day cluster all bust at trade #420 on 2013-08-29, the $2,000 intraday products at trade #419 on 2013-08-28, the MFFU Builder $1,500 add-on earliest at #401 on 2013-07-31, and the legacy $2,500 floor not until trade #1936 on 2020-03-25. First-bust trade number, fund-at-inception at two micros: the seven-product $2,000 end-of-day cluster all bust at trade #420 on 2013-08-29, the $2,000 intraday products at trade #419 on 2013-08-28, the MFFU Builder $1,500 add-on earliest at #401 on 2013-07-31, and the legacy $2,500 floor not until trade #1936 on 2020-03-25.
At two micros, seven separately branded $2,000 end-of-day products all bust at the identical trade #420 (2013-08-29). That identical failure point is the convergence.

Why did Apex look more forgiving under its old $2,500 drawdown?

At two micros our book needs $2,100 to clear its 2013 stretch, so the legacy $2,500 floor carried it to trade #1936 in 2020, while the current $2,000 floor fails at trade #420 in 2013.

A floor-width sweep at two micros shows our book needs $2,100, on the end-of-day and the intraday basis alike, to clear the 2013 stretch that kills a fund-at-inception account on the current rules. So the legacy Apex $2,500 floor was enough to get past it: it carries from inception all the way to trade #1936 (March 25, 2020, the COVID crash). The current $2,000 floor fails at trade #420 in 2013; a floor just $100 wider clears it. The $500 cut from $2,500 to $2,000 is precisely what flips our book from survive to bust. That is why a comparison citing the $2,500 number made Apex look "most forgiving," and why publishing that retired figure as current was both wrong and load-bearing. The lock matters even more than the width: with a floor that locks at start plus $100, every width from $2,100 up survives the whole record at two micros, and at one micro every width we tested, $1,500 to $3,000, survives. We use the legacy width only as a contrast; we do not model or recommend the retired plan.

Floor-width sweep: at fund-at-inception two micros, a $2,000 trailing floor busts at trade #420 in 2013, while $2,100 is the first width that clears the 2013 stretch on both the end-of-day and intraday basis and carries through to March 2020. The legacy $2,500 carries to trade #1936 in 2020. The $500 cut from $2,500 to $2,000 flips our book from survive to bust. Floor-width sweep: at fund-at-inception two micros, a $2,000 trailing floor busts at trade #420 in 2013, while $2,100 is the first width that clears the 2013 stretch on both the end-of-day and intraday basis and carries through to March 2020. The legacy $2,500 carries to trade #1936 in 2020. The $500 cut from $2,500 to $2,000 flips our book from survive to bust.
At two micros our book clears the 2013 stretch at $2,100 and above, and dies in it at $2,000. The retired $2,500 figure sat on the surviving side of that line.

Which platform is safest for an Apex evaluation, Tradovate or Rithmic?

On our book, Rithmic or WealthCharts. There the Apex evaluation floor locks at $53,000, while on Tradovate it trails forever, which moves the one-micro bust rate on the intraday evaluation from 8.1% to 99.4%.

Within Apex alone, the platform choice swings the outcome more than any difference between the three firms. On Rithmic or WealthCharts the evaluation floor stops trailing once it reaches the $53,000 mark; on Tradovate it trails $2,000 behind the peak forever and never locks. That single choice moves the one-micro bust rate from 8.1% to 99.4% on the intraday evaluation, and from 3.9% to 99.4% on the end-of-day one, a larger effect than any gap between the three brands. The lock point, not the logo, is the variable that matters. A related but smaller effect: intraday-ratchet products bust earlier than their end-of-day twins (trade #419 versus #420 at two micros, #358 versus #361 at three micros), because the floor ratchets up on the position's unrealized high.

How many NQ micros can a 50k prop firm account survive?

At one micro on a lock-at-breakeven product, the book is genuinely survivable: 97.5% of historical start dates survive. At two micros that falls to 81.7% on TopStep and 81.0% on Apex's end-of-day funded account, and at three micros to under 60%. Tradovate busts more than 99% of start dates at any size. The answer to "how many contracts" is one, and only on a floor that locks at breakeven.

At one micro, the consistency cap, the other rule traders worry about, barely touches this book. Firms typically cap the share of profit that can come from a single day at 50%. On our record the best single day is only 1.7% to 2.1% of positive-day profit over the run to a $3,000 target, at one to three micros, because our profit is spread across hundreds of days, not one windfall. That holds at micro size only. In a separate replay of a 50k evaluation ($3,000 target, $2,000 end-of-day floor) from 2,289 start dates, the cap binds in 2.4% of passing runs at one micro, but at one NQ mini per signal it binds in 40.1% of them under TopStep's 55%-of-target cap and 37.9% under Take Profit Trader's 50%-of-net cap. The honest caveat at one micro is time, not the cap: funded at the start of the record, one micro does not bank $3,000 net until trade #1488, on April 27, 2018, because the book lost money in 2011, 2012 and 2013. We work the general case, where a fat-tailed book and a short cap collide, in why a fat-tailed book and a short consistency cap are structurally opposed.

Methodology

Instrument: MNQ micro. The mini NQ is an instant kill (the book's worst intrabar drawdown of $28,515 is 14.3 times a $2,000 floor). Source: our TradingView List-of-Trades export dated November 6, 2026, 3,139 trades, net $696,891.60, November 16, 2011 to November 6, 2026, 2,291 distinct exit days; the replay reproduces the book's published trade count and net exactly, and commission of $4.10 per contract round trip and slippage are already netted in the export. Engine: each trade is replayed in exit-time order against each firm's trailing floor as a state machine. Worst intrabar equity (balance plus the open trade's adverse excursion) is checked before every trade for every firm, because all three enforce the floor in real time on unrealized loss even where the ratchet updates end-of-day. Sizing is a fixed M micros on every signal: the book's result for one contract, times 0.1, times M, with micro costs at a tenth of the mini's, and tables at M of 1, 2 and 3; M=1 is one MNQ, the smallest tradeable size. Rolling-start results run over all 2,291 historical fund dates; medians are taken over busted starts only.

The rules, with primary sources and retrieval dates:

What would falsify this: if any firm's current 50k drawdown is not $2,000, or its lock point differs from what we modeled, the convergence result breaks. These third-party rules carry an expiry and are re-verified quarterly; last re-checked October 5, 2026.

The limits we will state plainly

The intraday-floor reconstruction assumes an instant ratchet and does not let a trade's own favorable excursion pre-lift its floor before that same trade's adverse excursion is checked, so our intraday bust counts are a lower bound: intraday harshness is understated here, never overstated. The legacy Apex $2,500 plan is modeled with an infinite lock because we did not re-model its legacy lock rules, so its 98.5% one-micro rolling-start bust rate is dominated by that assumption and is not comparable to the current lock-bounded products; use its single inception result for the $2,500-width contrast only. And a state machine over a fixed 15-year sequence measures how this exact book met these exact rules. It is not a forecast of a different book, a different size path, or a different market. One more limit matters more than the rest, and it cuts against us. Every survival rate here comes from the order history actually dealt, varied only by start date. When we reshuffle the same 3,139 trades 10,000 times, the backtest ordering lands at the 5th percentile of drawdowns: about 95 of every 100 orderings drew down more than we did, and roughly one in twenty went past $51,684 for the book as traded. A deeper drawdown against a fixed floor busts sooner, so most orderings would produce worse survival numbers than the ones on this page. We have not put all 10,000 orderings through the floor state machine, so we are not going to quote you an adjusted bust rate we did not compute. The direction of that tail is not in doubt. The method behind the reshuffle is in expect a worse drawdown than your backtest.

What to do differently tomorrow

Stop comparing prop-firm brands. Compare two things: where the drawdown floor locks, and which platform trails it. For a real momentum book like ours, run exactly one micro, only on a product whose floor locks at breakeven, and never on a platform whose floor never locks. Then open the firm's own current 50k rule page and confirm with your own eyes that the drawdown reads $2,000, not a grandfathered $2,500, and run that floor and your own lock point through the prop-firm trailing drawdown calculator. To price what failed attempts cost before a pass, see combine reset math. For the drawdown math behind sizing this small, see why you should expect a worse drawdown than your backtest and why we trade MNQ micros instead of NQ minis, and for how long this book stayed underwater, how long trading drawdowns last. The full book, with its losing years and its stated limits, is on our tear sheet; if you would rather run the finished signals than build and babysit the machine, that is what we sell on our pricing page.


Conflict disclosure: we trade this book live and we sell access to the signals. Judge the data accordingly.

CFTC Rule 4.41: Hypothetical or simulated performance results have certain limitations. Unlike an actual performance record, simulated results do not represent actual trading. Also, since the trades have not actually been executed, the results may have under- or over-compensated for the impact, if any, of certain market factors, such as lack of liquidity. Simulated trading programs in general are also subject to the fact that they are designed with the benefit of hindsight. No representation is being made that any account will or is likely to achieve profit or losses similar to those shown.

Past performance is not indicative of future results.

See what STS NQ futures signals are and how they reach you and our forward record, every live signal we have sent, dated and public.

Hypothetical performance disclosure (CFTC Rule 4.41). These results are based on simulated or hypothetical performance results that have certain inherent limitations. Unlike the results shown in an actual performance record, these results do not represent actual trading. Also, because these trades have not actually been executed, these results may have under-or over-compensated for the impact, if any, of certain market factors, such as lack of liquidity. Simulated or hypothetical trading programs in general are also subject to the fact that they are designed with the benefit of hindsight. No representation is being made that any account will or is likely to achieve profits or losses similar to these being shown.

Past performance is not indicative of future results. Trading futures involves substantial risk of loss.