NQ vs ES, YM and RTY: We Ran Our NQ System on Every Index and Only NQ Passed
We took the exact rules that made money on NQ, in a previous five-strategy version of our book, and ran them, unchanged, on ES, YM, and RTY (data as of June 2, 2026). The answer was short: only NQ had a real edge. ES, YM, and RTY all scored 25% or lower on the edge test and failed. The book we trade now, four strategies on NQ, passes the same test, clearing the >90% robustness threshold.
Some of the other markets still made raw money. ES booked $122,662 on that previous version. But raw money is not an edge. The rest of this article shows the gap between the two, and why we trade and sell NQ only.
Whose trades are these (read this first)
These numbers are from our own book. Four systematic NQ strategies run as one single-position portfolio, meaning only one trade is ever open at a time. TradingView backtests, November 2011 to November 2026 (data as of November 6, 2026), 1 or 2 NQ minis a trade (2 when daily ranges are small, 1 when they are large; at today's index level every trade since July 2024 has been 1 contract), commissions and slippage included. The NQ book made $696,892 net over that window.
The ES, YM, and RTY results come from a previous five-strategy version of the book, data as of June 2, 2026. We have not yet tested the current four-strategy rules on those markets, so every non-NQ figure on this page is that previous version's, and we label it that way.
The style is momentum and trend continuation. Intraday plus one overnight model. Not mean reversion, not scalping.
That matters for this test. We did not re-tune anything for ES, YM, or RTY. We loaded the same Pine strategy, switched the chart symbol, and let it run. So this is a fair transfer test: take rules built for one market, move them to another, and see if the edge comes along. We are asking one question. Does the edge live in the rules, or does it live in NQ?
What a discretionary trader can take from this is the method, not our numbers. You can run the same check on your own system. Clone your rules onto a different market, change nothing, and look at the statistics, not the dollar total. Our exact results are ours. The test is yours to copy.
Does the NQ system work on ES, YM and RTY?
No, on the evidence we have. On a previous five-strategy version of the rules, only NQ showed a real edge, with a t-stat above 3.0. ES made $122,662 but scored a -0.20 t-stat and a 24.5% Deflated Sharpe, and YM and RTY also failed.
Here is the core result: four markets, full history, costs included. The NQ row is the book we trade now, data as of November 6, 2026. The ES, YM, and RTY rows are the same test on the previous five-strategy version, data as of June 2, 2026, each with that version's own sizing. Max drawdown is the worst peak-to-trough loss, stated for every market as a percentage of the peak equity that market had built when the dip began, so all four rows sit on one ruler. The t-stat and Deflated Sharpe are the two edge tests, both explained below.
| Market | Net P&L | Max drawdown (% of peak equity) | t-stat | Deflated Sharpe | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NQ (Nasdaq-100), current book | $696,892 | $25,342 (3.1% of peak), still open | >3.0 | >90% | Real edge |
| NQ (Nasdaq-100), previous version: the same rules as the three rows below | $1,112,232 | $51,836 (4.3% of peak) | >3.0 | >90% | Real edge |
| ES (S&P 500), previous version | $122,662 | $110,967 (106%) | -0.20 | 24.5% | Fails |
| YM (Dow), previous version | $6,650 | $63,911 (42%) | -0.37 | 3.5% | Fails |
| RTY (Russell 2000), previous version | $5,121 | $67,929 (52%) | -0.20 | 3.6% | Fails |
Look at ES first. It shows a $122,662 profit. At a glance that looks like the system works on the S&P too.
It does not. Two columns kill it.
The t-stat is below zero. A t-stat measures how far the average trade is from zero, scaled by how noisy the trades are. Around zero means no edge. For a real edge, researchers want a t-stat above 3. NQ clears that bar. ES, on the previous version, is at -0.20, which is essentially zero. The small ES profit looks like money on the chart, but trade by trade it is statistically indistinguishable from a coin flip. The dollars came from a few lucky years, not a repeatable edge.
The drawdown is the second nail. ES's worst peak-to-trough loss was 106% of the peak equity it had built. On NQ, the book we trade now has a worst closed-trade drawdown of $25,342, 3.1% of the peak it fell from. On ES, the previous version of the same rules lost more than the entire account. A real trader running it on the S&P would have been wiped out before the small profit ever showed up.
YM and RTY are even clearer. Each made only a few thousand dollars across 15 and 9 years. Their t-stats are basically zero. That is not a small edge. That is noise.
On that previous version, all four markets made money. Only one cleared the line that says the result is real. That second thing is the only one worth paying for.
What does the Deflated Sharpe ratio check?
Whether a result is real after accounting for how many markets were tried and for outlier trades. A score above 90% means the edge survives. Our current NQ book clears it. On the previous version, ES scored 24.5% and YM and RTY scored under 4%.
The Deflated Sharpe is the strictest number in the table, so it is worth one plain paragraph.
A normal Sharpe ratio just asks: how good was the return for the risk taken. The problem is that if you test a strategy on enough markets, one of them will look good by luck alone. The Deflated Sharpe corrects for that. It asks: after accounting for the fact that we tried this on several markets, and for the wild outlier trades in the data, what is the chance this result is real and not luck.
A score above 90% means the edge survives that haircut. NQ clears it, both in the book we trade now and in the previous version. ES scored 24.5%. YM and RTY scored under 4%. We ran the same test, the same way, on all four markets with the previous version of the rules. Only NQ lived through it.
This is the same test we run before any strategy goes in our book. We did not invent it for this article. It is a standard academic method (Bailey and Lopez de Prado), and it is built to catch exactly this kind of "looks profitable, is actually noise" trap.
How deep were the drawdowns on ES, YM and RTY?
On the previous version of the rules, ES hit 106%, a blown account. YM reached 42% and RTY 52%, deep holes to climb out of for almost no reward.
There is one more reason the raw P&L lies. The small profits on ES, YM, and RTY came with risk that would have ended the account.
In the book we trade now, NQ's deepest closed-trade dollar drawdown is $25,342, which is 3.1% of the $804,557 peak it fell from. On a fixed $100,000 account the same drop is 25.3%. It began on August 4, 2026 and was still open at the end of the record, so it is deeper than every drawdown the book has finished and it may yet grow. Survivable, but not small and not over. Two things to hold apart before you treat any of this as the number to plan around. First, 20.4% is a DIFFERENT episode measured a different way: in the book we trade now it is the deepest PERCENTAGE dip in the record, $20,432 below a $100,000 account between 2011 and 2014, and it is not the percentage of the $25,342 dollar dip. Second, $25,342 is the drawdown of the single trade order history happened to deal. Reshuffle the same trades 10,000 times and about 95% of the orderings come out worse, and one in twenty comes out deeper than $51,684. That is the whole argument of expect a worse drawdown than your backtest. It does not change the comparison on this page, because every market here is measured the same way, but it does mean you should plan for more than NQ's own figure, not less.
On the previous version, ES hit 106%. That is not a drawdown you sit through. That is a blown account. The profit ES eventually showed is a number you could never have reached, because you would have been stopped out of the game years earlier. YM at 42% and RTY at 52% are not account-enders, but they are deep holes to climb out of for almost no reward at the bottom.
So the honest read is not "the system makes a little on ES." It is "the system would have wiped the account on ES, and the leftover figure on the chart is fiction you could not have traded."
Does the NQ edge hold on gold, crude, bitcoin or Treasuries?
No, on the previous version of the rules. We ran that book on gold, crude oil, the euro, bitcoin and 10-year Treasury notes, and every one failed the edge test. NQ was the only market out of nine with a statistically real edge.
A fair question: did we just get lucky that our one chosen market is also the one that works? It is the obvious thing a skeptical trader would ask next.
We checked, with the same previous five-strategy version, data as of June 2, 2026. We did not stop at the four index futures. We ran the same book on gold, crude oil, the euro, bitcoin, and 10-year Treasury notes too. The pattern held. A couple printed raw dollars by riding a bull market (gold, bitcoin), but every single one of them failed the edge test, the same way ES did. Treasuries were the worst. There the rules lost money on average, with a t-stat of -10.
So NQ is not one winner we picked out of a row of winners. It was the only market, out of nine we tested, where the rules produced a statistically real edge. That is the whole point of the test. A real edge usually survives at least one honest move to a new market. A curve fit does not. A curve fit is a result shaped to fit past data rather than a real edge, and it dies the moment you move it. That is what these rules did everywhere but NQ.
The edge does not live in the rules alone. It lives in how these momentum rules fit the Nasdaq's specific behavior. NQ has a bigger intraday range. It trends harder once it goes. And it pays more for the few big opening drives that carry our profit.
If you want the deeper NQ-versus-ES breakdown, we wrote a whole piece on why NQ and ES behave so differently for this system.
How we measured this
The instrument set is the four CME index futures, no compounding, $100,000 nominal starting capital. NQ is the book we trade now: four strategies, 1 or 2 NQ minis a trade (2 when daily ranges are small, 1 when they are large; at today's index level every trade since July 2024 has been 1 contract), a TradingView backtest with data as of November 6, 2026 (3,139 trades). ES, YM, and RTY, and the five non-index markets, are a previous five-strategy version of the same Pine, with that version's own sizing, run per symbol inside TradingView over full available history, data as of June 2, 2026. We have not yet tested the current four-strategy rules on them. NQ, ES, and YM cover about 15 years; RTY has about 9 years of TradingView history. The system stayed active on every market, taking thousands of trades each, so these are real failures, not a case of the rules sitting out.
Costs are included. The backtests carry commission and slippage on every fill, the same settings on every market.
The Deflated Sharpe uses 20 trials as the multiple-testing count, a conservative number that covers the four index futures plus the other markets we screened.
One honest limit. The strategy keys off the 9:30 ET equity open, which is the right session for the index futures but not the natural session for assets like gold or crude, so treat the non-index results as a transfer screen, not a tuned test. The NQ book used here is the single-position book every number on this site reconciles to, and it clears the 3.0 significance hurdle and passes the >90% robustness threshold.
What would change our mind: if ES, YM, or RTY cleared a t-stat of 3 and passed the >90% robustness threshold on the same unchanged rules, the "NQ-specific" claim would be wrong. On the previous version they did not come close.
Judge a strategy by its statistics, not its dollar total. In the previous version's test, the same rules made money on all four markets and had a real edge on only one. A profit with a near-zero t-stat and a 100% drawdown is a story about luck and risk, not skill.
What to do with this
If you build or buy systems, do this one test before you trust any of them. Take the rules, clone them onto a market they were not built for, change nothing, and look at the t-stat and the Deflated Sharpe instead of the P&L. If it only works on the one market it was tuned on, and the dollars came with account-ending drawdowns, that is a curve fit, not an edge.
For us, this test is the reason the product is what it is. We do not sell a generic multi-market system, because we do not have one. We have a validated NQ specialist, and trying to stretch it across ES, YM, and RTY would only add drawdown and dilution, not diversification. ES in particular is 93% the same trade as NQ, so it cannot hedge it: why trading NQ and ES together is not diversification. You can see the four strategies and how they fit together on our strategies page, and the full performance record on the tear sheet.
If a single, statistically vetted NQ edge is what you want to trade alongside, that is exactly what our NQ futures signals, with the full 15-year record give you access to. One market, run the way the data says it should be run. Plans are on the pricing page.
Disclosure. We trade this book live and sell access to the signals, so judge the data accordingly. This article is educational and is not investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer to buy or sell any security or futures contract.
Hypothetical performance disclaimer (CFTC Rule 4.41). The results described here are based on backtested and hypothetical performance. Hypothetical performance results have many inherent limitations, some of which are described below. No representation is being made that any account will or is likely to achieve profits or losses similar to those shown. In fact, there are frequently sharp differences between hypothetical performance results and the actual results subsequently achieved by any particular trading program. One of the limitations of hypothetical performance results is that they are generally prepared with the benefit of hindsight. In addition, hypothetical trading does not involve financial risk, and no hypothetical trading record can completely account for the impact of financial risk in actual trading. For example, the ability to withstand losses or to adhere to a particular trading program in spite of trading losses are material points which can also adversely affect actual trading results. There are numerous other factors related to the markets in general or to the implementation of any specific trading program which cannot be fully accounted for in the preparation of hypothetical performance results and all of which can adversely affect actual trading results.
See our forward record, every live signal we have sent, dated and public.
Past performance does not indicate future results.